Anak Nogori Weekly Round-Up (20-26 July, 2026)
The six plaintiffs apply to recuse the presiding judge four days before the 28 July hearing, and BN offers itself as mediator in the royal dispute.
What happened last week
20 July 2026, Monday: Pakatan Harapan launched its state election manifesto. The document, themed “Negeri Sembilan Kekal Harapan” (Negeri Sembilan Stays With Harapan), sets out 10 commitments across the economy, jobs, welfare, education, housing and administration. Menteri Besar Aminuddin Harun, who is contesting the Linggi seat, said the manifesto builds on the coalition’s eight years in state office (The Edge Malaysia, 20 July 2026,Malay Mail, 21 July 2026).
23 July 2026, Thursday: The six plaintiffs applied to recuse the presiding judge. A notice of application was filed at the Seremban High Court seeking an order that Justice Roz Mawar Rozain withdraw from the originating summons, from the committal proceedings listed for 28 July, and from any further proceedings in the suit.
According to the filing, the plaintiffs came across two social media posts on or around 15 July, by users identified in the application as “Casper Azrul” and “Che GuBard”, alleging that the judge had appeared in photographs at an event, a Maal Hijrah (Islamic New Year) celebration on 16 June, at which the judge was seated beside the Tunku Ampuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan and at the same table as the wife of the Menteri Besar, the wife of the State Secretary and two state executive councillors, all of whom the application says have close links to the subject matter of the originating summons.
The plaintiffs, led by the Dato’ Shahbandar of Sungei Ujong, Datuk Seri Badarudin Abdul Khalid, who affirmed the supporting affidavit, said they then verified that Filed through Messrs Deidra, Sharina & Co, the application contends there is a “real danger of bias” engaging Sections 5 to 8 of the Judges’ Code of Ethics 2009, and asks that the recusal be heard as a matter of urgency before 28 July (The Edge Malaysia, 24 July 2026).
24 July 2026, Friday: Barisan Nasional offered itself as a mediator in the dispute. Speaking on KiniTV’s “Explain Sikit” podcast, BN Negeri Sembilan chairman Jalaluddin Alias said a mandate to govern the state would let the coalition facilitate a resolution between Yang di-Pertuan Besar Tuanku Muhriz and the Undangs, framing the dispute as a matter of crisis management and urging voters to weigh stability before polling.
He linked the present situation to the leadership of Menteri Besar Aminuddin Harun, and cited two precedents in support: the handling of royal immunity during Mahathir Mohamad’s first premiership, and a chieftaincy dispute during Mohamad Hasan’s tenure as Menteri Besar, in which the state government formed a committee of adat (customary law) experts whose findings went to the Dewan Keadilan dan Undang (DKU) for a final decision.
He contrasted the treatment of the chieftain in that case with the directives issued to vacate in Rembau and Sungei Ujong (Malay Mail, 24 July 2026).
On 18 July, BN deputy chairman Mohamad Hasan had told the coalition’s candidates to keep adat out of the campaign (Free Malaysia Today, 18 July 2026).
24 July 2026, Friday: Barisan Nasional launched its state election manifesto. The launch took place in Linggi and was performed by Mohamad Hasan. Jalaluddin Alias said a Manifesto Implementation Monitoring Unit has been set up to track delivery of each pledge (Utusan Malaysia, 24 July 2026).
24 July 2026, Friday: The Menteri Besar appointment power was drawn into the campaign. UMNO Secretary-General Asyraf Wajdi Dusuki, campaigning in Negeri Sembilan, asked who Pakatan Harapan’s Menteri Besar would be if Aminuddin Harun lost the Linggi seat, and named Anthony Loke of DAP. Loke replied that the coalition has one candidate only, Aminuddin, and that the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959 reserves the office for a Malay Muslim member of the assembly (Free Malaysia Today, 24 July 2026). DAP national vice-chairman Syahredzan Johan said the framing pre-empted the appointment, which under the state constitution rests with the Yang di-Pertuan Besar (Harapan Daily, 24 July 2026).
Commentary worth reading
20 July 2026, Monday: Negeri Sembilan State Polls Will Shape National Politics Tricia Yeoh, Visiting Senior Fellow at ISEAS, published an analysis of the state election for Fulcrum.
She writes that the royal dispute will likely be the centrepiece of the campaign, that political alignments are forming along the lines of the dispute, and that eleven seats were won on majorities under 1,000 votes in 2023. She sets out a scenario in which an UMNO-PAS state government could be formed, and notes that this would differ from the federal coalition arrangement (Fulcrum, 20 July 2026).
22 July 2026, Wednesday: Raja Pemerintah N. Sembilan bukan hanya jawatan adat
Utusan Malaysia carried remarks by senior lawyer Mohd Zainuddin Omar, who said that the ruling offices of Negeri Sembilan exist under law and are protected by the Federal Constitution and the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959, rather than being customary titles alone.
His argument is that a custom which has been codified into law is no longer merely a custom, but a valid law under the national legal system, carrying the force of law and enforceable as such. (Utusan Malaysia, 22 July 2026).
26 July 2026, Sunday: Negeri Sembilan has to be defended as if Malaysia is on its last leg: Coalition government can collapse
Phar Kim Beng, professor of Asean Studies at the International Islamic University Malaysia, published an opinion column in Malay Mail arguing that the 1 August election is a test of whether Malaysia can sustain stable coalition politics.
Coalitions put together for electoral convenience, he argues, cannot be relied on to govern well once in office, and durable government rests on agreement over principles, policy and a shared national vision. He casts Negeri Sembilan as a microcosm of the country, reflecting its ethnic, religious, Malay customary and political diversity. The piece is expressly the writer’s personal opinion (Malay Mail, 26 July 2026).
What we are watching for next week
28 July 2026, Tuesday: The Seremban High Court has the committal proceedings against the six plaintiffs listed, alongside the application by the DKU and its Secretary contesting the court’s jurisdiction under Article 16(3). The recusal application now sits across both. Whether it is heard first, and whether any stay is granted, will determine what proceeds on the day.
28 July 2026, Tuesday: Early voting for the 16th Negeri Sembilan state election
1 August 2026, Saturday: Polling day. 103 candidates are contesting 36 seats. Campaigning closes at 11.59pm on 31 July.
Summary
Two of the week’s developments point to different places for this dispute to be settled. The applications before the Seremban High Court treat it as a matter for the court, and they are presently arguing over which judge, on what date, and whether the court may hear it at all.
Article 16 of the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959 places questions of Malay custom, including the removal of a Ruling Chief, before the DKU, and Article 16(3) makes the DKU’s advice on those questions final and unchallengeable in any court.
The Adat saying goes, alur dan patut (by the proper channel and as is fitting). Every argument made this week, in the court file and on the campaign trail, was an argument about which channel that is.
New posts written by this publication last week
The publication’s Reference Library this is a reference library for the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959, where we explain the key articles in detail. It sits alongside our commentary as a plain English guide to the constitutional text at the centre of the current dispute. Each entry explains what an Article does, reproduces the original wording, and links to the pieces where we have written about it. New entries are added as the situation develops.
What is Article 11 of the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959?
What is Article 14 of the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959?
What is Article 15 of the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959?
What is Article 16 of the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959?
What is Article 17 of the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959?
Sources:
SPR tetapkan PRN Johor pada 11 Julai, Negeri Sembilan 1 Ogos (Portal Berita RTM, 12 June 2026)
Negeri Sembilan State Polls Will Shape National Politics (Fulcrum, 20 July 2026)
Raja Pemerintah N. Sembilan bukan hanya jawatan adat (Utusan Malaysia, 22 July 2026)
Asyraf Wajdi dahului kuasa Yang di-Pertuan Besar Negeri Sembilan (Harapan Daily, 24 July 2026)
Loke pans ‘malicious’ suggestions of him as MB (Free Malaysia Today, 24 July 2026)
About Weekly Round-Ups
Weekly Round-Ups are published every Monday morning. Each round-up covers what happened the previous week, what we are watching for in the week ahead, and links to posts published that week.
How to manage your subscription
When you subscribe to this Substack, you are subscribed to both formats by default: regular posts and Weekly Round-Ups.
To receive only the Weekly Round-Ups:
From any email: scroll to the bottom and click Unsubscribe or Manage subscription. You will see the option to opt out of regular posts while keeping the Weekly Round-Up.
From the website: go to Account Settings on Substack, find Anak Nogori under your subscriptions, and toggle off Posts while leaving Weekly Round-Ups on.
To unsubscribe entirely, click Unsubscribe at the bottom of any email, or use Substack’s account settings.
If you are new to this Substack, and are not sure where to begin, visit our Start Here page, where we list all our articles organised by theme.
Anak Nogori is independent commentary on the unfolding constitutional crisis in Negeri Sembilan, where centuries-old Adat Perpatih, royal succession law, and modern political manoeuvring are colliding in ways Malaysia has never seen before. If you find this useful, share it with someone who should be following this, or subscribe to receive the latest articles in your inbox.
